Recently during some of my management development groups, we’ve been talking about high performers. It always comes up as a topic. Some consider them like unicorns, some feel they have at least one in the team, others are terrified of losing them, so the conversation turns to how you keep them happy and challenged in the team. Occasionally we get so starry eyed about our star performers, we neglect everyone else. The same can be said of our team members who aren’t performing well. It’s one of those sad management truths that we spend a lot of our time on people who don’t give a lot back. Ah the joys of management.
While we are cramming every spare moment in to supporting our high and low performers, what happens to those in the middle? The terms for someone who is neither at their peak, nor at the end of your tether, are so awful: satisfactory, middle and solid performers… yuck – who wants to be described in such stodgy terms?
I’ve decided I’m renaming them and I’m going to call then our Quiet Stars. Because often, that’s exactly what they are.
Do you think you might have one in your team? Check out these characteristics.
If your team member fits a few of these, then chances are you have a quiet star in your midst. If so, the tendency is to leave them to it – even ignore or neglect them. It’s understandable, you’ve got enough on your plate. It’s also a big mistake to ignore your low maintenance people. They are the bedrock of your team and deserve your time too. Equally they may not want to have the light shined on them too much or too often, so here are three things you can do to support your steady performers:
High performers are fabulous – they can also be exhausting. The same can be said of low performers… without the fabulous bit. And in the middle, you have those who quietly get on with it. The person giving you the most good energy and good work, might be the one you haven’t really noticed, because their star shines quietly. I suggest you start noticing them.
Confession time, I’ve found a legit way to spy on my kids. Yes, I know they’re grown-ups, but I still worry about them. Having resisted the temptation to track them via mobile phones, a horrible infringement of their privacy not to mention a lifetime of worry for me, I’ve found an acceptable way of checking they got home safely after a night out. There’s a certain comfort in a Ring doorbell notification. They’re home, the door has closed behind them, and I know they’re safe. But there’s a fine line between using technology for reassurance and checking every movement just because you can.
The same tension exists at work. We live in a work world where managers can track online status, logins, activity, response times and hours at a desk. This may look like proof that people are working. Often, though, all they prove is that people know they are being watched. Otherwise, why would someone have invented the “mouse jiggler”?! Being visible is not the same as being productive.
This doesn’t have to mean absence of accountability. You can still be clear on expectations, suggest sensible check-ins and support when something goes off track. Monitoring is part of managing, but it should be proportionate, transparent and tied to a genuine need—not used as a substitute for being clear on expectations or having difficult conversations.
When your team feels watched, they tend to do things for effect to show they’re visible, such as the green status light, the instant reply, the crowded calendar, the obsession with “busy”. Deep thinking, experimentation, reflection and review are harder to display on a dashboard, yet they are often where the magic happens.
A doorbell camera should tell you your kids are safely home—not keep them under surveillance once they’re through the door. The same goes for your team. Check that people have what they need, agree what good work looks like, then get out of their way. They know you’re there if they need you.
So, take a long hard look at your management style. Is there a genuine wish to support your team members, or is it spying dressed up as support? Trust is a basic foundation of good team working, but if trust between you and them only lasts while the camera is on, it isn’t trust at all.
Want to help your managers build trust while keeping accountability clear?
At Sharpstone Skinner, we help leaders set expectations, have better conversations and give their teams room to do their best work.
Get in touch, and let’s talk about what would make a difference for your team.
To book a call with Helena Sharpstone, visit Contact us - Sharpstone Skinner
Quick gut check … when did you last do something at work that made you a bit uncomfortable? Put your hand up for a project you weren't sure you could pull off, or sat in a room as the least knowledgeable person there? If you're doing this constantly, gold star, you're exactly where you should be. If it's been within the year, not bad. If you're struggling to think of an answer at all – that's worth sitting with for a moment.
Here's the trap: the better we get at our jobs, the easier it becomes to stop stretching ourselves. Seniority buys us the option to stick to what we already know, and plenty of us quietly take it. But staying sharp isn't something that happens by accident as it takes a deliberate decision to keep putting yourself in the path of new knowledge and new experience, even when nobody's asking you to.
It feels like we've barely stopped shaking things up these last couple of years. AI has landed in most of our working lives whether we asked for it or not, hybrid working has settled into something more permanent than we expected, and the pace of change shows no sign of slowing.
You may feel fresher than ever and at the top of your game because you've had to keep adapting the way you work. Or you may just feel exhausted by it all. Either way, you should ideally make time for learning, and time is the one thing many of us are short of.
And, if that is unlikely to change for you any time soon, here are three quick-fire ways to actively bring learning into your working week: -
No one wants to stand still. Sometimes we think we do. We tell ourselves we'll tread water for a bit, enjoy the comfort of knowing what we're doing and after everything the last few years have thrown at us, who can blame us? That feeling won't last long. Humans live to learn, we want to grow and get better, and sometimes that means not being the cleverest, it means being a beginner again. As the saying goes: "If you are the smartest person in the room, you're in the wrong room."
If you work in fundraising, this isn't just a personal challenge, it's a strategic one.
Our founder Helena Sharpstone is joining THINK Recruitment at the Scottish Fundraising Conference in Glasgow this September to explore exactly this: how fundraising teams can identify the future skills their people will need, and how to go about building them. If you're heading to the conference, come along to the session.
Last month, we explored why positive workplace relationships matter and how trust helps teams perform at their best. This month, I'd like to look at the other side of the equation because while workplace friendships can be a huge positive, they also come with a watch-out.
Friendly teams work differently
Workplace friendships can create problems when they turn into cliques. A group that has worked together for years may have its own language, shared history and jokes that make perfect sense to them while leaving everyone else feeling as though they have arrived halfway through a complicated film.
Friendship becomes particularly unhelpful when decisions are made informally, information is shared selectively or the same people are always offered the most interesting opportunities.
A genuinely friendly team makes room for people. It doesn’t require everyone to have the same personality, attend every social event or reveal the contents of their personal life over lunch. It notices who hasn’t spoken. It explains the joke. It invites different opinions and makes sure that connection extends beyond the people who naturally gravitate towards one another.
Be the person who creates connection
You don’t need to be the manager, team leader or Chief Friendship Officer to influence the quality of the relationships around you. Small behaviours make a difference. Give someone your full attention, for example, rather than continuing to type while they talk. Check in without immediately following it with a request. Share useful information instead of quietly guarding it like the last biscuit in the tin.
Offer help, but don’t take over. Introduce people who would benefit from knowing one another. Give credit freely. Thank people properly. If something is bothering you, speak to the person involved rather than everyone else in the team. And most importantly, take an interest in colleagues who are not immediately like you.
It’s easy to connect with people who share our communication style, background, interests or sense of humour, and it takes more thought to build relationships with people who see the world differently. However, those relationships often stretch our thinking and make the greatest contribution to the team.
A small friendship check-up
Take a moment to think about the people you work with. Who makes your working day easier, more enjoyable or simply more human? Who listens, encourages you, challenges you thoughtfully or steps in when things become difficult?
Have you told them?
Then consider the other side of the equation. What are you like to work with? Do you create trust, connection and space for other people to contribute? Do you bring something useful to the team - not only through the work you produce, but through the way you make others feel?
You don’t have to be everyone’s best friend, but you can aim to be the person everyone wants on their team.
International Friendship Day takes place on 30 July. Before you start ordering matching bracelets for the entire team or organising a compulsory bonding session, don’t worry. We’re not suggesting you need to become best friends with everyone you work with.
Some people form lifelong friendships at work. Others prefer to keep their professional and personal lives neatly separated, with colleagues remaining firmly on the work side of the fence. Both approaches are valid, but there is a difference between having friends at work and working in a friendly workplace, and the latter matters more than we realise.
Friendly teams work differently
When people have positive relationships with their colleagues, they are more likely to ask for help before a small problem becomes a fire-breathing one. They feel able to float an unfinished idea without worrying it will be immediately shot down. They share information, offer support and give one another the benefit of the doubt.
Friendly teams are not necessarily teams where everyone agrees. In fact, trust can make disagreement easier. If you know your colleague respects you, and wants the best for the team, you are less likely to interpret a challenging question as a personal attack. You can argue about the idea without falling out with the person who suggested it.
That is an important distinction because the strongest teams are not endlessly harmonious. They contain different perspectives, working styles and opinions. The magic happens when people feel secure enough to express those differences plus skilled enough to explore them constructively.
Creating this kind of environment doesn't happen by accident. It grows through everyday interactions, mutual respect and the small behaviours that build trust over time. A friendly workplace isn't about everyone becoming close friends. It's about creating a culture where people feel safe to contribute, challenge ideas and support one another to do their best work.
Of course, there is another side to workplace friendships. While positive relationships can strengthen teams, they can also unintentionally leave others feeling excluded.
Next month, we'll explore how to create connection without creating cliques, the small behaviours that make teams more inclusive, and why you don't have to be everyone's best friend to become the person everyone wants on their team.
When was the last time you learned something and did you find the opportunity yourself or rely on someone else to do it for you?
We tend to think of training a bit like teaching – something we rely on others to drive; something that is done to us. Learning and development though is wider and has more opportunities for you drive your own growth. So how do you take control of your own learning in a fast-changing world, where time and attention both in work and outside are under pressure.? A good place to start is by adopting the 70:20:10 Model for Learning.
The 70:20:10 Model for Learning suggests we gain 70% of our knowledge from job-related experiences, 20% from interactions with others, and 10% from formal educational events.
Hands-on experience (the 70%) is the most beneficial for us because it enables us to discover and refine our job-related skills, make decisions, address challenges and interact with influential people within work settings. We also learn from our mistakes and can get in the moment feedback on our performance. If you ask an experienced person how they got to where they are now, they won’t tell you about what they studied, they will give you a list of experiences. How they got thrown in at the deep end, volunteered to take on a gnarly project, how they stumbled a few times, got up, wiped their grazed knees and learned from the experience to do better next time. 70% of what we learn, we learn by doing.
The model continues by suggesting that 20% of what we learn, we learn from others. This can be a formal arrangement like getting a coach or a mentor, as well as learning from your own manager. Or it might be informal like watching someone do something really good (or bad!) and learning from what you see. Now that we work in a more flexible way from a range of settings (hooray for that) the moments to see and learn from others are all the more precious.
And that leaves the final 10% - formal learning – a small but mighty piece of the puzzle. Study, courses, training events and workshops whether online or in-person still provide a great opportunity to add to our learning. This is the bit we tend to think of first when we talk about learning, because it’s usually a planned event. Make the most of these experiences and enhance them all the more by moving quickly from the formal learning applying it back at work – which puts you back in the 70% arena.
So, here’s a quick reminder:
70% of learning is experiential. It happens through learning on the job, including assignments, practice and trying things out.
20% of learning is social. It happens with and through other people managers and team members. It also includes mentoring, coaching and feedback.
10% of learning is formal. It happens through structured training events and programmes.
Create a world for yourself where you can manage your own development through doing, coaching, mentoring and generally putting your hand up for stuff, as well as the more traditional methods of training and education and see where it takes you. Make this year the one that you devote some time to your own development. Be prepared to invest in yourself. And as with any DIY, it’s all in the preparation.
Further information is available via the CIOF Convention. Helena will be speaking at 12:00pm on “Owning and driving your own development” (Fundraiser: Develop thyself).
There’s a common assumption that if you bring the right people together, with the right expertise, things will naturally fall into place. But experience tells us otherwise.
Just because you put a group of people together doesn’t mean they’ll work well together. Teams don’t succeed by default. They succeed when people understand how to communicate with one another clearly, honestly, and with intent. And yet, communication is often the one area we assume will “just happen”.
In many organisations technical expertise is rightly prioritised as it’s measurable, tangible and feels productive. But over time, something else becomes far more defining … your human skills, for example:-
These are the skills that don’t date. They travel with you, from role to role, and often determine how effective you truly are so it’s important to not let them fall by the wayside as your career progresses.
“Difficult conversations” is a topic that comes up time and again amongst our clients. Most people want to know how to handle them better, but the bigger issue is that many of us avoid them altogether.
We soften what needs to be said. We delay. We hope the situation resolves itself, yet left on its own, it rarely does.
When things go unsaid problems tend to grow quietly in the background, and by the time they surface, they’re harder, more emotional, and more complex than they needed to be. In reality, the most effective conversations aren’t dramatic or confrontational. They are honest, genuine and clear.
Another misconception we often see is around negotiation. It’s frequently framed as something combative — a win/lose scenario. But in practice, the most effective negotiators approach it differently in that they see negotiation as a trade.
It’s about, for example, understanding what matters to both sides and finding a way forward through conversation. When you shift your mindset from “winning” to “trading”, communication becomes more open, more constructive, and far more productive.
Strong communication isn’t about saying everything, all the time. It’s about knowing:
That balance isn’t always obvious. It requires awareness, confidence, and experience and I find it’s often where individuals and teams need the most support. In fast-moving environments, where teams are under pressure and expectations are high, communication can easily slip down the priority list. When it does, the impact is felt quickly:
The opposite is also true, so when communication improves, even slightly, everything else tends to follow.
Communication isn’t a “soft” skill. It’s a foundational one and in many cases, it’s the difference between a team that simply exists… and one that truly works.
If this resonates, and you’re noticing similar patterns in your team or organisation, it may be time to take a closer look at how communication is really working in practice. At Sharpstone Skinner, we support individuals and teams to develop the confidence and capability to communicate with clarity, especially when it matters most.
You can listen to the podcast here.
Everyone is talking about gut health and its link to wellness – our social media feeds are full of it (well okay, mine are), we’re bombarded with products aimed at maintaining a happy gut and if we’re not careful, we end up swallowing so many different supplements, we start to rattle when we walk.
What on earth does any of it have to do with effectiveness at work? As it happens, quite a lot. In a world powered by facts, data and intelligence - artificial or otherwise, you should never ignore your gut feeling.
Here’s the medical bit. The enteric (think all things intestinal) nervous system that regulates our gut is sometimes referred to as the body’s “Second Brain”. Although it can’t do long division or write a report, it’s an extensive network using the same chemicals and cells as the brain, to help us digest and alert the brain when something is amiss. So, the gut and brain are in constant communication. But we aren’t always listening.
When things are out of whack with the gut, we can experience symptoms that hamper our effectiveness at work. It might be fatigue, lack of focus, mood changes or just feeling unwell generally. Any of those things affect how we show up and how we contribute. The way we work now – from a range of locations, non-traditional hours, tech driven, online meetings – can be fantastic for our work/life balance yet lousy for our gut health.
If you’ve fallen in to a pattern of long hours in front of a screen, rarely taking a break and jumping from one meeting to the next without a breather, you’ll know the impact this can have on your general wellbeing, yet you may not have considered that this is linked to gut health. But it is. In the same way our working practices can negatively impact how our gut feels, small changes can equal a happier, more settled gut.
Here are a few to get you started – gold star if you’re doing them already:
One of the team at Sharpstone Skinner, Juan Carlos Herrera, is a specialist in this area and runs workshops and sessions about gut health and wellbeing at work. He’s based in Spain and visiting the UK in April, around World Health Week. Lots of our clients have booked him to come and speak as part of their commitment to workplace wellbeing.
Do get in touch with us if you’d like to run something similar in your organisation. Your team and your gut will thank you.
We’re really pleased to share that our new Sharpstone Skinner website is now live, alongside a refreshed brand that better reflects who we are and how we work.
The new site highlights our approach to development more clearly, from how we support leaders and teams, to the values that shape everything we do. It’s more human, more focused, and designed to give you a real feel for what it’s like to work with us.
At the heart of everything we do is a simple belief: real development starts with real people. We don’t believe in off-the-shelf solutions or surface-level change. Instead, we take time to listen, understand your world, and ask the questions that truly matter. It’s this approach that helps leaders grow, teams work better together, and organisations perform at their best, while keeping wellbeing, humanity, and the future firmly in view.
While our look has evolved, our purpose hasn’t changed. We’re still about listening first, tailoring our work to real contexts and settings, plus helping people and organisations grow in ways that genuinely last. You’ll also see more about who we work with, from charities and purpose-driven organisations to professional services firms, SMEs, public sector teams, and household names. What unites them is a desire to learn, connect, and lead with purpose, often at moments of growth or change.